The most important game of this ALCS is not game 4. It’s not game 5. It’s game 6. If you don’t win game 6, you are going to have to win game 7. Period. And with Cliff Lee pitching, you are going to struggle doing that. That’s why you have to pitch CC on short rest tonight. Then you throw Burnett in game 5. Back him up with a couple innings of Hughes on short rest is you have to. Doesn’t matter. If you lose game 5, no biggie. You have Petitte game 6 and CC game 7. But if you WIN game 5, and are UP 3-2, you now have a chance to close out the series with Petitte, who pitched extremely well last night. Would you rather have Petitte on short rest or Hughes on regular rest? Well, on regular rest, Hughes got destroyed by the Rangers in Game 2. Is there any reason to think he won’t have the same results in game 6?
CC game 4, Burnett/Hughes game 5, Petitte game 6, CC game 7.
